You Can’t Have It All

Barbara Ras’s poem ‘You Can’t Have It All’ encapsulates life’s richness and limitations, urging readers to appreciate fleeting moments, cherish memories, and find contentment amid the unattainable.

The poem explores themes of gratitude, acceptance, and the complex tapestry of human experiences through imagery and contemplative reflections. The speaker emphasizes the value of relationships, memories, and small pleasures, guiding readers to find solace in what can be embraced while acknowledging the inherent constraints of existence.

Summary

The poem ‘You Can’t Have It All’ by Barbara Ras explores the notion that while life offers a multitude of experiences and emotions, one cannot attain everything.

The poem begins with vivid imagery of nature – a fig tree with lush leaves and the gentle touch of a child’s finger. It introduces the reader to the mundane yet meaningful aspects of life, like being awakened by a child for a simple reason.

The poem continues with descriptions of companionship and empathy, symbolized by the purring cat and the soulful gaze of a dog. The poet conveys the message that love, although often perplexing, is a significant part of life, comparing it to mysterious white foam that rises from a pot. The analogy between foam and blood underlines the complexity of emotions.

Physical and sensual experiences are also addressed, with the solidity of a man’s skin and the allure of passion fruit and saliva. The life of the mind is celebrated and described as glowing without pettiness or bribery. It touches upon the ability to speak foreign languages and the power of forgiveness and forgetfulness.

As the poem unfolds, it reminds us of the transient nature of life, the inevitability of loss, and the importance of memory. It speaks of gratitude for simple pleasures, like makeup and towels, and for profound experiences, like music and dreams. The poem portrays the guidance of friends in navigating life’s challenges and the value of learning about love and surrender.

The juxtaposition of distant places, such as Egypt, and familiar moments, like a grandfather’s presence, captures the variety of life experiences. The poem acknowledges the limitations of adulthood while asserting that a unique, comforting voice – reminiscent of a mother’s – remains within, reminding us that life is a collection of moments that can’t all be captured but can still be cherished.

In essence, ‘You Can’t Have It All’ celebrates the richness and diversity of human existence while acknowledging the inevitability of limitations, urging readers to embrace the moments they can possess, finding solace in what is available rather than lamenting what cannot be attained.

Structure and Form

The poem ‘You Can’t Have It All’ by Barbara Ras is structured as a single stanza consisting of forty lines, adhering to a free-verse form. The poet’s deliberate choice to avoid traditional stanza breaks or rhyme schemes emphasizes the seamless flow of life’s varied experiences and emotions.

The absence of distinct stanza breaks mirrors the interconnectedness of the poet’s thoughts, suggesting that life’s moments are intertwined and don’t fit neatly into defined compartments. This form encourages readers to move through the poem without interruption, mirroring the continuous journey of life itself.

The poem’s free-verse structure allows for flexibility in line length and rhythm. Some lines are short and concise, while others are longer, conveying a sense of both urgency and contemplation. The use of enjambment – carrying a sentence or phrase from one line to the next without pause – creates a dynamic reading experience, mirroring the ebb and flow of thoughts and emotions.

This structure also complements the content of the poem, as it delves into various aspects of life, from nature to relationships to memory. The single-stanza form mirrors the accumulation of diverse experiences into a singular existence.

Barbara Ras employs vivid imagery and sensory details in her descriptions, and the lack of stanza breaks enhances the immersive quality of these images, enabling readers to vividly visualize the fig tree, the touch of a child’s finger, the purring cat, and other scenes.

The free-verse form contributes to the conversational and introspective tone of the poem, creating an intimate connection between the reader and the speaker. The absence of rigid rhyme schemes and metrical patterns emphasizes the natural flow of thoughts and emotions, aligning with the themes of acceptance and appreciation for life’s imperfections.

In essence, the poem’s single-stanza free-verse structure reflects the seamless and interconnected nature of life experiences, enabling readers to navigate the various facets of existence without interruption while also fostering a sense of intimacy and contemplation.

Themes

Barbara Ras addresses several themes in her poem ‘You Can’t Have It All,’ weaving them seamlessly into the fabric of life’s complexities.

One prominent theme is the ephemeral nature of existence, depicted through fleeting moments like the touch of a child’s finger or the memory of a black swan. These moments symbolize the transience of life’s experiences, as exemplified in the line, “You can’t bring back the dead.”

Another theme is gratitude for life’s simple pleasures, evident in the appreciation of everyday sensations like towels on clean skin and the kiss of makeup. These instances reflect the importance of finding joy in the mundane, as expressed in the lines “You can be grateful for makeup, the way it kisses your face” and “for deeper thirsts, for passion fruit, for saliva.”

The theme of acceptance resonates throughout the poem, emphasizing the idea that life isn’t about having everything but rather about cherishing what is attainable. This theme is encapsulated in the recurring phrase, “You can’t have it all, but there is this.”

Love and its complexities are explored, portraying love as mysterious and multifaceted. The comparison of love to white foam over red kidneys conveys both its enigmatic nature and its potential to be overwhelming, reflecting the line, “You can have love, though often it will be mysterious.”

The poem also touches on the theme of nostalgia and memory, evoking sentimental recollections like a grandfather’s presence or childhood experiences. The line “There is the voice you can still summon at will like your mother’s” illustrates the power of memory to comfort and guide.

Human connections are celebrated, evident in descriptions of companionship with animals and the guidance of friends. These connections provide a sense of comfort and support, as seen in lines like “And when adulthood fails you, you can still summon the memory.”

The theme of diversity of experiences emerges as the poem spans from nature to emotions, from foreign languages to familial moments. The poem’s structure mirrors life’s varied dimensions.

In essence, ‘You Can’t Have It All’ delves into themes of life’s impermanence, gratitude for the ordinary, acceptance, love’s intricacies, memories’ significance, human connections, and the multiplicity of experiences that constitute a meaningful existence.

Poetic Techniques and Figurative Language

• Imagery: Barbara Ras employs imagery to vividly depict moments and sensations, enhancing the poem’s sensory impact. The fig tree with “fat leaves like clown hands gloved with green” paints a striking visual, and the image of “foam’s twin is blood” creates a visceral connection between love and its complexities.
• Metaphors: These play a significant role, such as comparing the touch of a child’s finger to a “single eleven-year-old finger” and characterizing the dog’s gaze as one that would “bite every sorrow until it fled.” These metaphors convey tenderness and empathy.
• Simile: The simile “half spice, half amnesia” describes makeup kissing the face, evoking a unique sensory experience. Another simile likens foreign language to something meaningful, illustrating the power of communication.
• Symbolism: The use of this technique is evident in the black swan, symbolizing cherished memories from childhood. The line “There is the voice you can still summon at will like your mother’s” uses voice as a symbol of comforting guidance.
• Enjambment: This maintains the poem’s flowing narrative, mirroring life’s uninterrupted progression. For instance, “and when it is August, / you can have it August and abundantly so” reflects the fluidity of time and experience.
• Contrast: It is employed to highlight life’s paradoxes. The juxtaposition of love’s mysterious nature with foam rising over kidneys portrays love’s complexity.
• Repetition: The phrase “You can’t have it all, but there is this” employs repetition for emphasis, reinforcing the poem’s central message of cherishing available moments.
• Alliteration: The poem incorporates alliteration in lines like “the horses of Egypt and you riding in the hot sand,” enhancing the rhythmic quality of the text.
• Analogy: These amplify the themes, as in the analogy between love and foam over beans. This helps convey the intricate nature of emotions.

Detailed Analysis

Lines 1-8

But you can have the fig tree and its fat leaves like clown hands
gloved with green. You can have the touch of a single eleven-year-old finger
on your cheek, waking you at one a.m. to say the hamster is back.
You can have the purr of the cat and the soulful look
of the black dog, the look that says, If I could I would bite
every sorrow until it fled, and when it is August,
you can have it August and abundantly so. You can have love,
though often it will be mysterious, like the white foam

In the opening lines of Barbara Ras’s poem, ‘You Can’t Have It All,’ the speaker introduces a message centered on the value of appreciating life’s simple yet profound moments. The imagery of the “fig tree and its fat leaves like clown hands gloved with green” evokes a sense of abundance and whimsy. The juxtaposition of the fig tree’s leaves to “clown hands” suggests a joyful and playful quality, inviting readers to perceive the beauty in everyday elements of nature.

The speaker emphasizes the significance of human connection through tactile experiences. The touch of an “eleven-year-old finger on your cheek” carries a sense of innocence and purity. The specificity of the age underscores the tender vulnerability of childhood. This touch awakens the recipient at an early hour, symbolizing the unexpected yet meaningful interruptions life brings. The presence of the hamster’s return, though trivial, becomes a catalyst for connection between individuals, highlighting the importance of shared experiences even in the most ordinary circumstances.

Through the imagery of the purring cat and the soulful look of the black dog, the poem conveys a deeper emotional resonance. The black dog’s gaze that desires to “bite every sorrow until it fled” encapsulates an empathetic response to pain and suffering. This image communicates the profound comfort that companionship can provide, portraying animals as silent companions willing to alleviate human distress.

The reference to August as a time that can be had “abundantly so” underscores the theme of embracing each moment fully. August is often associated with the height of summer, a season of warmth and vitality. This conveys the message of embracing the present with a sense of abundance, extracting the fullest essence of every experience.

The theme of love’s enigmatic nature emerges through the analogy of “white foam.” This simile, comparing love’s mystery to foam on top of a bean pot, evokes a sense of intrigue and complexity. Just as foam can appear unexpectedly and disappear swiftly, love’s manifestations can be elusive and fleeting.

These opening lines establish a thematic foundation emphasizing the value of cherishing everyday moments, nurturing connections, and embracing the fullness of experiences. The imagery of nature, touch, companionship, and love, all characterized by their unique qualities, serves to convey a message of gratitude and presence in a world that often demands attention to life’s subtleties. Through these lines, Barbara Ras prompts readers to recognize the profound beauty within the ordinary and to approach life with open-hearted appreciation.

Lines 9-16

that bubbles up at the top of the bean pot over the red kidneys
(…)
You can speak a foreign language, sometimes,

In lines 9 to 16 of Barbara Ras’s poem, the poet continues to explore themes of love, intimacy, intellectual richness, and the complexities of human experiences. Through the metaphor of “foam” transitioning into “blood,” Ras delves into the nature of love’s profundity. The foam’s transformation into blood suggests a deeper, more primal connection between emotions and the core of human existence. This metaphor implies that love, while appearing ethereal like foam, is also intrinsically tied to the essence of life, much like the fundamental nature of blood.

The poem then shifts its focus to the realm of physical intimacy, referencing the “skin at the center between a man’s legs.” The vivid imagery of the “skin” conveys a sense of vulnerability and intimacy. Describing it as “so solid, so doll-like” evokes a juxtaposition between strength and fragility, echoing the complexity of human vulnerability in moments of closeness.

The phrase “life of the mind” introduces the theme of intellectual and spiritual richness. The imagery of the mind “glowing occasionally in priestly vestments” evokes a sense of reverence and illumination. This portrayal of the mind suggests moments of transcendence and insight, hinting at the capability of thought to elevate human experiences beyond the mundane.

The lines “never admitting pettiness, never stooping to bribe the sullen guard who’ll tell you all roads narrow at the border” convey a message of integrity and authenticity. The refusal to succumb to “pettiness” and the determination to face truths even in challenging situations highlight the importance of moral courage. The image of “all roads narrow at the border” signifies the inevitability of limitations in life, emphasizing the importance of confronting them without compromise.

The mention of speaking a foreign language introduces the theme of communication and cultural exploration. This linguistic ability represents the bridge between different worlds and the capacity to connect with diverse individuals.

In these lines, Barbara Ras combines metaphoric language, vivid imagery, and philosophical reflections to underscore the interconnectedness of emotions, the complexities of intimacy, the richness of the mind, the importance of integrity, and the power of communication. These themes collectively contribute to the poem’s overarching message of embracing life’s various dimensions with a sense of depth and appreciation.

Lines 17-24

and it can mean something. You can visit the marker on the grave
(…)
for passion fruit, for saliva. You can have the dream, 

In lines 17 to 24 of ‘You Can’t Have It All,’ Barbara Ras explores themes of memory, forgiveness, gratitude, artistic expression, and the embrace of diverse experiences. Through the assertion that speaking a foreign language “can mean something,” the poet highlights the significance of communication as a conduit for understanding and connection across cultures and languages.

The lines “You can visit the marker on the grave where your father wept openly” introduce the theme of memory and loss. This imagery evokes a sense of emotional vulnerability and the longing to commemorate significant moments. The acknowledgment that one “can’t bring back the dead” emphasizes the inescapable reality of mortality, underscoring the importance of cherishing memories.

The juxtaposition of “forgive and forget” holding hands suggests a tension between forgiveness and memory. The phrase “as if they meant to spend a lifetime together” portrays these concepts as intertwined, signifying the complex interplay between letting go of past grievances and acknowledging their enduring impact.

The theme of gratitude emerges through the imagery of makeup, Mozart’s music, towels, and sensual experiences like passion fruit and saliva. The phrase “the way it kisses your face, half spice, half amnesia” characterizes makeup as both enhancing and concealing, reflecting the dual nature of appearances. The reference to Mozart’s music as “racing one another towards joy” highlights the ability of art to evoke profound emotions.

The imagery of towels “sucking up the drops on your clean skin” is symbolic of renewal and cleansing. This mundane act becomes a metaphor for appreciating life’s smaller pleasures. The reference to “deeper thirsts” and sensual experiences like “passion fruit” and “saliva” speaks to the range of human desires, underscoring the poem’s celebration of both the physical and emotional aspects of existence.

The phrase “You can have the dream” introduces the theme of aspirations and imagination. This line hints at the limitless potential of dreaming and the creative realm, extending the idea that life’s richness includes not just tangible experiences but also the intangible world of hopes and aspirations.

In these lines, Barbara Ras combines introspection, vivid imagery, and philosophical reflections to convey a message of cherishing memories, embracing forgiveness, finding gratitude in diverse experiences, and acknowledging the profound impact of art, culture, and dreams. The poet encourages readers to engage with life’s complexities and treasures, both tangible and intangible.

Lines 25-32

the dream of Egypt, the horses of Egypt and you riding in the hot sand.
(…)
until you learn about love, about sweet surrender, 

In lines 25 to 32, the poet delves into themes of imagination, memory, guidance, and personal growth, revealing the complex interplay between dreams, relationships, self-discovery, and the acceptance of life’s unpredictability.

The imagery of the “dream of Egypt” and “horses of Egypt” conjures a sense of exoticism and allure. The hot sand and the act of riding in this dreamlike landscape evoke a sensation of freedom and adventure, symbolizing the boundless nature of the human imagination and the pursuit of unattainable experiences.

The image of one’s “grandfather sitting on the side of your bed” is infused with nostalgia, evoking a sense of familial warmth and connection. This temporary presence signifies the fleeting nature of cherished memories and moments.

The phrase “clouds and letters, the leaping of distances” introduces a theme of communication and distance, both literal and metaphorical. This imagery symbolizes the exchange of thoughts across vast spaces, echoing the theme of understanding and connection across physical and emotional barriers.

The reference to “Indian food with yellow sauce like sunrise” blends sensory experiences, celebrating the sensory richness of cuisine and its power to evoke emotions and memories. The comparison to “sunrise” implies a fresh start and renewal.

The lines “You can’t count on grace to pick you out of a crowd, but here is your friend to teach you how to high jump, how to throw yourself over the bar, backward” depict the value of friendship and guidance. The act of high jumping becomes a metaphor for overcoming challenges and taking risks. This image suggests that while life may not always provide graceful solutions, having friends who offer support and teach resilience is essential.

The phrase “until you learn about love, about sweet surrender” encompasses a central message of the poem. This journey of self-discovery and vulnerability is portrayed as a path toward understanding love’s intricacies and the beauty of letting go.

Barbara Ras underscores the power of imagination, memories, relationships, and personal growth in shaping a meaningful life. The poem encourages readers to embrace the richness of experiences, both real and imagined, and to seek wisdom from friends and challenges alike. Ultimately, it highlights the transformative potential of engaging with life’s complexities and learning to surrender to its ebbs and flows.

Lines 33-40

and here are periwinkles, buses that kneel, farms in the mind
(…)
it will always whisper, you can’t have it all,
but there is this.   

In the concluding lines (33-40) of Barbara Ras’s poem ‘You Can’t Have It All,’ the poet reinforces the central message while introducing themes of nostalgia, resilience, and acceptance. These lines encapsulate the poem’s essence, highlighting the value of cherishing meaningful moments and memories in the face of life’s limitations.

The image of “periwinkles, buses that kneel, farms in mind as real as Africa” conveys a vivid and diverse sensory experience. This imagery contrasts real-world elements with imaginative ones, suggesting that the realms of memory and imagination are as valid as concrete reality. The “buses that kneel” symbolize readiness for embarkation, representing life’s continuous journey.

The phrase “when adulthood fails you” introduces the theme of disillusionment and resilience. It acknowledges that life’s expectations and realities often diverge, potentially leading to disappointment. This concept underscores the poem’s central message that life cannot be fully controlled or experienced in its entirety.

The memory of the “black swan on the pond of your childhood” and the “rye bread with peanut butter and bananas your grandmother gave you” evoke a sense of nostalgia and comfort. These specific memories symbolize moments of simplicity and innocence. The grandmother’s gesture of providing nourishment while others slept reflects a deeper care and connection.

The theme of legacy and influence emerges through the line, “There is the voice you can still summon at will, like your mother’s.” This suggests the lasting impact of a mother’s guidance, reinforcing the notion that life’s experiences are carried forward through generations.

The phrase “you can’t have it all, but there is this” reiterates the central message, inviting readers to acknowledge life’s inherent limitations while appreciating the profound depth of what is attainable. This concluding statement encapsulates the poem’s themes of acceptance, gratitude, and the recognition that life is a collection of unique, treasured moments.

In these final lines, Barbara Ras crafts a poignant conclusion that encompasses the poem’s overarching themes. The images of memory, imagination, resilience, and intergenerational connection converge to reinforce the message that life’s richness lies in embracing what can be cherished, even when confronted with life’s inevitable constraints.

FAQs

Similar Poetry

Those who enjoyed this poem by Barbara Ras may also wish to explore the following other poems:

• ‘A Brave and Startling Truth’ by Maya Angelou is a commonly quoted poem about humanity’s future. The poet alludes to the “truth” that humanity will arrive at when “we” realize we are the one true wonder of the world. 
• ‘A Woman Waits for Me’ by Walt Whitman is all about the power of regeneration, procreation, and creativity.
• ‘A Dialogue Between the Soul and Body’ by Andrew Marvell describes the conflict between the human body and the human Soul, each attributing its troubles and sufferings to the other.