I Was Not False To Thee

Caroline Norton

‘I Was Not False to Thee’ by Caroline Norton is a poem about loneliness and a speaker’s feelings of unequal treatment.


Caroline Norton

Nationality: English

Caroline Norton was born in 1808 in London and remembered today as a poet and social reformer.

She wrote numerous poetry collections including The Sorrows of Rosalie: A Tale with Other Poems, I Do Not Love Thee, and The Cold Change.

Key Poem Information

Unlock more with Poetry+

Central Message: Love is not always fair

Speaker: A bereft lover

Emotions Evoked: Confusion, Passion

Poetic Form: Octave

Time Period: 19th Century

This is a beautifully emotional poem that explores the ways that love, in all its forms, can cause suffering.

This is a heartbreaking poem that explores one speaker’s longing to dress the disparity between their emotions and those of their beloved. They are desperate to make this person believe in their devotion and faithfulness, something that’s seen through the poet’s use of repetition throughout this poem.


‘I Was Not False To Thee!‘ by Caroline Norton is a beautifully written piece that expresses a speaker’s desire to remain faithful and devoted to their loved one.

In the first lines of this poem, the poet’s speaker begins by addressing their beloved. In these lines, they emphasize their own loyalty and constancy. They describe their physical and emotional decline, contrasting it with the apparent happiness and indifference of their partner.

They question why they alone bear the burden of suffering when they have remained true. The poem concludes with a bittersweet realization that, in the future, their beloved may come to remember and appreciate their fidelity, even though the narrator will continue to feel the pain until the end.

Structure and Form

‘I Was Not False to Thee!’ by Caroline Norton is a lyric poem that consists of three stanzas. Each of these has eight lines, known as an octave. The rhyme scheme throughout the poem is ABABCDCD, alternating end sounds from stanza to stanza.

This regular rhyme scheme helps to create a sense of musicality and rhythm within the poem. Additionally, the repetition of the line “I was not false to thee” in each stanza serves as a refrain, providing a unifying element and reinforcing the central theme of loyalty.

Literary Devices

In this poem, the poet makes use of a few different literary devices. For example: 

  • Repetition: can be seen when the poet repeats the same word or phrase multiple lines throughout a poem. For example, the use of the refrain “I was not false to thee!” which is seen in every stanza.
  • Caesura: occurs when the poet inserts a pause into the middle of a line of text. For example, “Thou wert the same; thy looks were gay.”
  • Anaphora: the repetition of the same word or phrase at the beginning of multiple lines. For example, “My” starts three lines in stanza one.

Detailed Analysis

Stanza One

I was not false to thee, and yet
My cheek alone looked pale;
My weary eye was dim and wet,
My strength began to fail.
Thou wert the same; thy looks were gay,
Thy step was light and free;
And yet, with truth, my heart can say,
I was not false to thee!

In the first stanza of this emotional poem, the speaker, who is likely the poet herself, declares their faithfulness to their beloved while describing their own physical and emotional state.

The narrator asserts in these lines that despite their current condition, they have remained true and faithful to their beloved. As the lines go on, the poet writes that the narrator’s physical appearance reflects their inner turmoil. The paleness of their cheek implies a loss of vitality or a sense of melancholy.

In contrast to the narrator’s worsening condition, the beloved/love interest is depicted as unchanged. The line “Thou wert the same; thy looks were gay” highlights the stark difference between the narrator and their beloved. While the narrator is suffering, the beloved appears cheerful and unaffected.

Stanza Two

I was not false to thee, yet now
Thou hast a cheerful eye,
With flushing cheek and drooping brow
I wander mournfully.
I hate to meet the gaze of men,
I weep where none can see;
Why do I only suffer, when
I was not false to thee?

In the second stanza of the poem, the narrator continues to express their emotions and contrasts their own state with that of their beloved.

The stanza begins with a repetition of the declaration of faithfulness: “I was not false to thee, yet now.” The narrator reaffirms their loyalty, emphasizing that they have remained true to their beloved.

The next line describes the beloved’s cheerful demeanor with the line, “Thou hast a cheerful eye.” The contrast between the narrator’s sadness and the beloved’s cheerfulness becomes even more apparent.

The narrator then expresses their discomfort in social interactions: “I hate to meet the gaze of men.” This could suggest a withdrawal from society and an aversion to facing others.

Stanza Three

I was not false to thee; yet oh!
How scornfully they smile,
Who see me droop, who guess my woe,
Yet court thee all the while.
‘Tis strange! but when long years are past,
Thou wilt remember me;
Whilst I can feel until the last,
I was not false to thee!

In the third and final stanza of the poem, the narrator reflects on the reactions of others to their suffering, expresses a sense of estrangement, and shares a bittersweet realization about the future.

The stanza begins with a repetition of the affirmation of faithfulness: “I was not false to thee; yet oh!” The narrator once again asserts their loyalty to their beloved.

The next line introduces the reactions of those around them: “How scornfully they smile.” The tone here could suggest that the people who witness the narrator’s emotional distress respond with contempt or derision.

Despite witnessing the narrator’s anguish, these individuals around them continue to court the beloved: “Yet court thee all the while.” This suggests that while the narrator is left to suffer, their beloved receives attention and affection from others, further exacerbating the narrator’s feelings of injustice and abandonment.

The final lines conclude with the narrator acknowledging their own enduring emotions. The poet writes, “Whilst I can feel until the last, I was not false to thee!” This line encapsulates the narrator’s steadfastness and unwavering commitment.


Why is ‘I Was Not False To Thee’ repeated in Caroline Norton’s poem?

The repetition of this phrase emphasizes the narrator’s commitment and serves as a refrain to highlight their enduring faithfulness amidst adversity.

What is the central theme of ‘I Was Not False To Thee’ by Caroline Norton?

The narrator’s unwavering loyalty and fidelity to their beloved, despite their own suffering and the indifference of others, is the central theme of the poem. The poet’s speaker repeats a number of times how important their own faithfulness is.

What is the tone of ‘I Was Not False To Thee?’

The tone of this beautiful Norton poem is one of melancholy. The narrator’s words carry a sense of sadness and emotional burden, reflecting their suffering.

What kind of poem is ‘I Was Not False To Thee?’

This piece can be categorized as a lyric poem. It expresses the personal emotions, thoughts, and experiences of the narrator in a reflective and introspective manner.

Similar Poetry

Readers who enjoyed this poem might also want to read some other Caroline Norton poems. For example:

Poetry+ Review Corner

I Was Not False To Thee

Enhance your understanding of the poem's key elements with our exclusive review and critical analysis. Join Poetry+ to unlock this valuable content.

Caroline Norton

Caroline Norton was a prominent English poet and social reformer in the 19th century. 'I Was Not False To Thee' demonstrates Norton's ability to convey emotional depth and evoke empathy through her poetic expressions. Her work reflected the societal constraints and gender roles of her time, giving voice to personal experiences and the struggles faced by women in Victorian society. This is a good example of her verse that should be counted among her best.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+

19th Century

This poem belongs to the tradition of 19th-century poetry, characterized by its focus on personal sentiment, introspection, and romantic themes. It reflects the Romantic era's emphasis on individual emotions and the exploration of inner thoughts and struggles.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


This poem is a representative example of poems by English poets, particularly from the Romantic era. It demonstrates the poetic sensibilities, emotional depth, and introspective qualities often found in the works of English poets of that time. Despite this, Norton, and her poetry, are not regarded as the most influential elements of the 19th century.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


This poem addresses questions of identity within the context of a relationship. The narrator's sense of self and identity is challenged as they grapple with the discrepancy between their own suffering and the indifference of others.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


The poem explores the narrator's deep and unwavering love for their beloved. It highlights the narrator's commitment and loyalty despite their own suffering, raising questions about the nature of love and its impact on one's emotional well-being. The poem also underscores the enduring power of love and its complexities.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


The poem delves into the dynamics of relationships, particularly the unequal distribution of emotional burdens between the narrator and their beloved. It highlights the narrator's suffering while their beloved remains seemingly unaffected. The also poem touches upon the challenges and conflicts that can arise within relationships.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


The poem touches upon the narrator's confusion regarding the unequal treatment they receive in the relationship. They express confusion over why they alone suffer while their beloved is seemingly unaffected. This suggests a certain degree of vulnerability and uncertainty.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


This beautiful Norton poem captures the intensity of passion in the narrator's love for their beloved. Despite their suffering, the narrator's passion remains unwavering, emphasizing the depth of their emotions and the power of their devotion.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+

Breaking Up

The poem implies a sense of impending or unrequited separation in the relationship. The narrator's suffering and the contrast between their state and the happiness of their beloved suggest a potential breakdown in the relationship. The poem also captures the pain and emotional upheaval associated with the dissolution of a romantic bond.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


The poem alludes to the inevitability of change over time. It hints at the possibility that the beloved may come to recognize the narrator's loyalty and sufferings in retrospect. This is something that has yet to happen, though.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


Devotion is a central theme in the poem, as the narrator repeatedly emphasizes their unwavering loyalty and faithfulness to their beloved. It portrays the narrator's steadfast commitment and enduring love, emphasizing their devotion even in the face of hardship and emotional challenges.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+

Trust Issues

The poem hints at trust issues within the relationship. The narrator's observation that others court their beloved despite witnessing the narrator's suffering implies a lack of trust or doubts regarding the beloved's faithfulness.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+


An octave poem refers to a poem composed of eight lines in a specific rhyme scheme. 'I Was Not False To Thee' follows this structure, consisting of three stanzas, each comprising eight lines, with a rhyme scheme of ABABCDCD. The use of the octave form in this poem provides a balanced and cohesive structure.
To unlock content, or join Poetry+
Emma Baldwin Poetry Expert
Emma graduated from East Carolina University with a BA in English, minor in Creative Writing, BFA in Fine Art, and BA in Art Histories. Literature is one of her greatest passions which she pursues through analyzing poetry on Poem Analysis.

Join the Poetry Chatter and Comment

Exclusive to Poetry+ Members

Join Conversations

Share your thoughts and be part of engaging discussions.

Expert Replies

Get personalized insights from our Qualified Poetry Experts.

Connect with Poetry Lovers

Build connections with like-minded individuals.

Sign up to Poetry+
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Got a question? Ask an expert.x

We're glad you like visiting Poem Analysis...

We've got everything you need to master poetry

But, are you ready to take your learning

to the next level?

Share to...