Departed To The Judgment by Emily Dickinson

This particular poem, Departed To The Judgment, coincides with Dickinson’s own beliefs about herself. While all around her, people in what was called “The Great Awakening” expressed that they had given their lives over to God, Dickinson considered herself “one of the lingering bad ones”((The Dickinson Properties). It is interesting that she referred to herself in that manner.  It is as if there was a part of her that longed to believe and have the assurance of life after death that everyone around her seemed to have, but for some reason she couldn’t. She did not argue that others were wrong in their beliefs. She simply expressed her own inability to adhere to the same philosophical ideals.

Many of her poems reveal her fear of death. Because I could not Stop for Death reveals her feelings that death is a trickster that will come to steal you in the night. In I Felt a Funeral in my Brain and I Heard a Fly Buzz – When I Died she expresses her discontentment with the idea of her own death. As she tries to imagine, something is always not quite right. Something is missing. Something is less than peaceful. Thus, it makes sense to conclude that she wished she could have assurance in death, like everyone around her seemed to have. That is the main teaching of Christianity, after all, that one might be certain of his eternity because of a belief in Jesus Christ. But Dickinson did not feel this assurance. Poem after poem reveals her agitated feelings toward the idea of her own death. Time and time again, she tried to imagine it.

In many of her poems, she writes as a speaker from beyond the grave. It is as if she has already gone there herself, or at least made every attempt to imagine life after death. These poems are so moving because everyone has contemplated death at one point or another, and most fear death more than anything else. Dickinson’s poems are certainly less than comforting. They do not offer assurance of life after death. They do not offer comfort at the loss of a loved one. They do not promise eternity in paradise, or any such thing. Rather, they exemplify Dickinson’s feelings toward death. They reveal feelings of fear, discontentment, and uncertainty. These are all feelings that readers can deeply relate with when they think about death.


Departed To The Judgment Analysis

Stanza 1

DEPARTED to the judgment,
A mighty afternoon;
Great clouds like ushers leaning,
Creation looking on.

Emily Dickinson has a way of beginning her poems with a phrase curious enough to leave the readers fascinated. She begins this poem with “Departed to the judgment”. The word “Departed” was written in all capital letters, placing emphasis on that word. “The judgment” is commonly understood according to the Christian beliefs about life after death. Growing up surrounding by Puritan ideals and the teachings of “The Great Awakening”, Dickinson was sure to have heard countless ideas about judgment day. Early American Christians believed that when a person died, his or her soul was taken before God for judgment. There, the person would either be judged by his or her own actions, and cast away from God forever, or that person would be seen as perfect because he or she had believed in Jesus Christ. The main teachings of her time included the idea that no one could enter into heaven based on his or her good life. The Puritans strove to live pure lives, but not because they thought it would get them past judgment day. Jonathan Edwards, in his famous sermon “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” reveals God’s anger at any and all sin. He also suggests that God’s arms are open wide to receive any who have believed that Jesus’ death on the cross paid the price for all sins. This is the message that Dickinson grew up surrounded by. Departed To The Judgment itself doesn’t reveal her personal beliefs, only that she imagines that she is “departed” and gone “to the judgment”.


Stanza 2

The flesh surrendered, cancelled,
The bodiless begun;
Two worlds, like audiences, disperse
And leave the soul alone.

The speaker uses the words “surrendered” and “cancelled” to describe what happens to “the flesh”. She express that “the bodiless” has begun. This refers to yet another Christian doctrine, the doctrine of the resurrection. The Christian church taught that when a person died, they would remain “bodiless” until the resurrection day, which was a day when people would receive their new and glorified bodies. So as the speaker imagines her own death, she expresses that she is now “bodiless”. She then says that “two worlds” disappear before her eyes. It is unclear exactly what those two worlds are. One of them is likely this earth. The other is possibly heaven, but it remains ambiguous. The speaker feels like an actor after the audience has left. She describes herself as a “soul alone”. It is unclear where she has gone, but it would appear that the speaker believes that she is to be left utterly alone.


Emily Dickinson and Departed To The Judgment Background

Dickinson’s life experiences certainly shaped her feelings toward death. During Dickinson’s early years, she experienced the death of many people close to her, including that of her cousin. It is easy to see why she felt familiar with death. Dickinson also lived near a cemetery, so she watched many people, even loved ones riding in a hearse to their final resting places. This is a likely inspiration for the setting of Departed To The Judgment. In times of sorrow, she would likely have heard sermons about salvation, paradise, and mansions waiting in eternity. Most of her poems, however, reveal that she did not accept these teachings. Rather, she continued to view death as something she feared. Her poetry reveals her attempts to become comfortable with the idea of her own death, to embody it, to imagine it, but she cannot. Every attempt to write from beyond the grave reveals her own feelings of uncertainty.

Works Cited:

  • “The Dickinson Properties: The Evergreens | Emily Dickinson Museum.” The Dickinson Properties: The Evergreens | Emily Dickinson Museum. The Emily Dickinson Museum, 2009. Web. 02 Dec. 2015.
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

What's your thoughts? Join the conversation by commenting
We make sure to reply to every comment submitted, so feel free to join the community and let us know by commenting below.

Get more Poetry Analysis like this in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get new poetry analysis updates straight to your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Scroll Up